While most people know that sound doesn't travel in a vacuum, that doesn't stop filmmakers. The sounds of TIE Fighters and space weapons in Star Wars are famous, for instance, despite being totally unrealistic. It makes sense from a filmography standpoint--silence can build suspense, but it has more trouble expressing the intensity of a space battle. If space battles were ever to become a reality, these sounds would probably have to be synthesized by a computer based on other information--sort of like most of the sounds in the Buzzfeed article.
It's interesting to think about whether there was a time when sound in space wasn't such an impossibility. The ability of sound to propagate through a fluid (liquid, gas, or plasma) is dependent on the fluid's density and compressibility. As cosmology teaches us, the Universe went from really-really-ridiculously dense at its inception to not-all-that-dense now, which means that it necessarily passed through a period of sort-of-normal-Earth-atmosphere density (all technical terms, of course). I don't know how early in the Universe's life this was or how long it lasted, but it's possible that the Universe was once a very noisy place.
*Insert TIE Figher screech* |
Sources:
http://www.buzzfeed.com/alexkasprak/cool-ass-space-noises-that-will-make-you-feel-like-an-astron
https://soundcloud.com/nasa/cassini-saturn-radio-emissions-2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_OSeRxhGOY
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_sound#Dependence_on_the_properties_of_the_medium
http://57.media.tumblr.com/be7ebf9987a76f4dc337894f8355c641/tumblr_mtdq4muTvC1rth2h5o2_400.gif
https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/state.html
Fun. Also for a space movie/TV show that gets the silence right, check out Firefly :)
ReplyDeleteThe original Alien folks had it right: and early ad read: "In space, no one can hear your scream." That is where the realism ended--but a wonderful series, nonetheless...
ReplyDelete--Dad